Beshert | From Longing to Belonging

By | Oct 01, 2021
Beshert, Latest
Rabbi Edelstein with family In Iceland, 2016. Beshert.

Seeing the first smile on my ten-day-old daughter’s face and observing her daily development, I was convinced of God’s presence. Science could not explain the emergence of her soul. Although I’d grown up in a secular Jewish family, at that moment I became determined to pass on the legacy of Judaism to her.

As an obese child growing up in Brooklyn, I was both a social outcast and an outsider to the Jewish community. I longed to connect to the transcendent. An older sibling lectured me on the superiority of atheism. My family provided few religious resources; rather, a sort of nationalistic pride and chicken soup.  I was jealous of the children in my neighborhood who exuded something special in their dress-up clothes going to synagogue with their parents on Shabbos

As a young adult, I dragged my Jewish, religiously disinterested husband with me to every synagogue on the Upper West Side of Manhattan. Nothing fit. Not knowing Hebrew or any rituals left me feeling like an outsider again. I looked out of our apartment window at the synagogue across the street year after year, longing to be a part of the crowd and for something indescribable.

As soon as my daughter was eligible, I sent her to afternoon Hebrew school. Simultaneously, I took adult education classes at neighborhood synagogues. One of my teachers helped me understand that God is a presence in my life that could be whatever I wanted: a source of comfort, moral conscience, and inspiration to be the best person I can possibly be. 

When my son was born a few years later, my commitment to creating a Jewish home became a passion. He went to a Jewish nursery school. We joined a congregation renowned for its music and progressivism. I admired and wanted to emulate my rabbis. But how?  I had no Jewish education. Although I got a job with and for Jews at an institute, I still craved deeper connection.

Then one morning, I brought my son to nursery school and spotted a flier for The Academy for Jewish Religion, a pluralistic rabbinic seminary focused on second career adults. I picked up the flier, something I rarely do. I called the Dean. We spoke for an hour. She encouraged me to study Hebrew and to apply the next year. With a leap of faith, that is exactly what I did. I finally found what I had longed for all my life.  

Five years later, in May, 1997, I cried my way through my ordination. Today, I teach at Manhattan’s Marlene Meyerson JCC, the Mussar Institute and privately. I love my students – what fulfillment! Simply because I noticed a flier on a table.

That beshert glance out of the corner of my eye changed my life. I now belong to the synagogue across the street.

March 2021, with grandkids Stahv and Reah

Judith with grandkids Stahv and Reah, March 2021


Rabbi Judith Edelstein

Besides her teaching, Rabbi Judith Edelstein provides spiritual counseling, prepares students for conversion and serves as High Holiday rabbi of Nantucket, MA. She has been a pulpit rabbi and chaplain and worked for synagogues, long term care facilities and Jewish organizations. Before being ordained, she was a public school English teacher and college professor. She holds a BA and MA in English and Creative Writing from City College of New York and is currently writing a book about aging. She lives with her husband, Jim Meier, in Manhattan.


Top image: Rabbi Judith Edelstein with family in Iceland, 2016: left to right, Judith, son Jacob, daughter Joslyn, son-in-law Nir and baby Stahv riding dad’s shoulders.


One thought on “Beshert | From Longing to Belonging

  1. I love this story. It reminds me of the concept of “pintele yid” the tiny spark of yearning inside the Jewish soul.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.