DEBATERS
Mira Sucharov is a professor of political science at Carleton University, the author most recently of Borders and Belonging: A Memoir, and coeditor of Social Justice and Israel/Palestine: Foundational and Contemporary Debates.
Derek Penslar is a comparative historian and a professor of Jewish history at Harvard University. He is the author or editor of a dozen books, including the forthcoming Zionism: An Emotional State.
3 thoughts on “Moment Debate | Has the Word Zionism Outlived its Usefulness?”
Given the wide variety of sentiments toward the philosophic positions of Israel’s current leadership, and also because of the complex baggage carried by the term, the use in any way of ‘Zionism’ has become meaningless and probably counter-productive.
Our enemies have attempted to paint the word ZIONISM as an Evil word. We must continue to SUPPORT ZIONISM. Would it be any different if our enemies painted the words JEW or Jewish as evil — should we then eliminate the words JEW and JEWISH from the international vocabulary — Absolutely NOT.
.
One must remember that we are all AM YISRAEL, the People Of Israel. Likewise, we are all ZIONISTS, let us not forget Ahavat Zion — our love of Zion. Just as we must fight Anti-Semitism, likewise we must defend against Anti-Zionism. If we eliminate ZIONISM then we have eliminated Midinat Yisrael, the State Of Israel.
The word zionist means a supporter of a Jewish state and there is one currently and it is the State of Israel. I support it and its continued existence. I do not support its Government, which is not a requirement of zionism. I do support a two state solution, which is also not contrary to zionism.